Cannibalism and Violence in the Prehistoric American Southwest
Christy G. Turner II and Jacqueline A. Turner
Anthropology / Archaeology
This study of prehistoric violence, homicide, and cannibalism explodes the myth that the Anasazi and other Southwest Indians were simple, peaceful farmers.
Until quite recently, Southwest prehistory studies have largely missed or ignored evidence of violent competition. Christy and Jacqueline Turner’s study of prehistoric violence, homicide, and cannibalism explodes the myth that the ancestral Puebloan and other Southwest Indians were simple, peaceful farmers. Using detailed osteological analyses and other lines of evidence the Turners show that warfare, violence, and their concomitant horrors were as common in the ancient Southwest as anywhere else in the world.
The special feature of this massively documented study is its multi-regional assessment of episodic human bones assemblages (scattered floor deposits or charnel pits) by taphonomic analysis, which considers what happens to bones from the time of death to the time of recovery. During the past thirty years, the authors and other analysts have identified a minimal perimortem taphonomic signature of burning, pot polishing, anvil abrasions, bone breakage, cut marks, and missing vertebrae that closely matches the signatures of animal butchering and is frequently associated with additional evidence of violence. More than seventy-five archaeological sites containing the remains of several hundred individuals are carefully examined for the cannibalism signature. Because this signature has not been reported for any sites north of Mexico, other than those in the Southwest, the authors also present detailed comparisons with Mesoamerican skeletal collections where human sacrifice and cannibalism were known to have been practiced. The authors review several hypotheses for Southwest cannibalism: starvation, social pathology, and institutionalized violence and cannibalism. In the latter case, they present evidence for a potential Mexican connection and demonstrate that most of the known cannibalized series are located temporally and spatially near Chaco great houses.
Christy G. Turner II is regents’ professor in the Department of Anthropology at Arizona State University.
The late Jacqueline A. Turner was a ranch manager in Dragoon, Arizona.
Table of Contents:
1. Introduction: Studying Southwestern Cannibalism
2. Interpreting Human Bone Damage: Taphonomic, Ethnographic, and Archaeological Evidence
3. Taphonomic Evidence for Cannibalism and Violence in the American Southwest: Seventy-Six Sites
4. Comparative Evidence: Cannibalism and Human Body Processing in Mexico
5. Conclusion: Explaining Southwestern Cannibalism
List of Figures
List of Tables
Index to Sites
Praise and Reviews:
“The Turners make their case convincingly and methodically, but not at the cost of producing an interesting and thought-provoking book. The renegade anthropologists have advanced a theory that has breathed life into a moribund debate, while producing a book absolutely worth reading even for those outside the field.”
—San Francisco Bay Guardian
“A fascinating theoretical glimpse into the collapse of a great civilization.”
—Los Angeles Times
“Sure to be one of the most controversial books on Southwestern archaeology of our generation.”
“A remarkable achievement, a joy to read, and a sobering learning experience. This book is one of the few that truly belong on the shelf of every Southwestern archaeologist.”
“The first detailed account of cannibalism and violence on a regional scale in the prehistoric American Southwest, especially in the Chaco Canyon area. It’s a shocker.”
—High Country News
“A major contribution to understanding taphonomic signatures of human violence and cannibalism and to Southwestern prehistory. Debates over interpretation aside, the Turners’ legacy of objective reporting of the evidence will endure.”
—Journal of Anthropological Research
“Recommended to readers who want more extensive knowledge of the Anasazi world.”
—Colonial Latin American Historical Review
“A carefully research, fully documented argument for cannibalism in the ancient Southwest. Well written, cleanly edited, and handsomely designed. By far the most extensive treatment of the subject, and the only sustained argument for cannibalism as a political tool. The book presents solid research, with all the information required for critical independent testing by other scientist. Man Corn presents significant scientific research that cannot fail to focus the factions of the ‘science wars’ on archaeology, and the relative values for data and discretion in archaeology’s search for truth.”
—The Journal of Arizona History
“Belongs to that tradition of grand, ‘big picture’ anthropological treatises that prioritize empirical data and comparative perspectives above all else and construct clearly written and authoritative arguments that virtually never stray from the patterns painstakingly drawn from the data. We are treated to precious few volumes with the breadth, ambition, authority, and diachronic perspective of Man Corn.”
“Both provocative and encyclopedic.”
—Latin American Antiquity